The AJ1 is about that raw, old-school basketball feel. The cushioning is minimal. That’s its "biggest" pro: authenticity. But also its con for some people. You’re buying a piece of history, not a cloud for your foot. On-camera, this shoe "pops". The contrast between the red, black, and white is just perfect for photos. Wearing it out, I got several compliments—it's that kind of shoe. The build feels durable, like it'll age well. My main gripe? The break-in period can be a bit rough on the heels. Still, as a classic red Air Jordan 1, it delivers on its promise. Conversely, who should "skip" it? If you're on a tight budget and need one ultra-comfortable, all-purpose shoe? Maybe pass. If your daily style is very muted, this much red might sit in the box. First-time AJ1 buyers might prefer a more neutral colorway to start. It's a specific vibe, not for everyone! Conversely, who should maybe skip it? If you're new to sneakers and prioritize comfort above all—this ain't it. Or if your wardrobe is very neutral/subdued, this red Air Jordan 1 might feel overwhelming. Also, if you already own several similar red or Chicago-style 1s, this might feel redundant unless you're completing a set.