You won't get buttery-soft leather like on some premium retros. But for this black colorway, it works. The structure holds up, and the creasing is part of the charm. It’s a workhorse sneaker. Don't expect luxury, expect durability and classic Jordan 1 DNA. Who should avoid it? If you're new to sneakers and expect modern comfort tech, you might be disappointed. Also, if you love bold color—this ain't it. The subtlety is its strength, but it could be boring for some. I'd say try it on first if you can, because that break-in period is a real factor to consider. Here's a real pro: these things are "tough". The black leather on this air jordan 1 hides scuffs and dirt incredibly well. They’re low-maintenance, perfect for city life or bad weather days. For someone who actually wears their sneakers and doesn't just shelf them, this is a huge advantage. Practicality wins. Conversely, who should "skip" the "black air jordan 1"? Anyone with wide feet or major comfort needs. Also, if you're new to sneakers and want that "pop" of color – maybe start with a different colorway. And if $180 feels steep for a shoe with "basic" tech, that's totally valid! This is about iconic design, not cutting-edge performance. Know what you're buying.