The 4 is bulkier and has more of a structured feel. Versus a lighter Retro like the 3 or 5, the 4 "Black Cat" feels a tad heavier due to all the overlays, but it's not uncomfortable—just "present". Who should skip it? If you prioritize all-day comfort above all, look elsewhere. Also, if you're rough on your shoes, the delicate suede might stress you out. And for true wide-footers, I’d try them on first. The "black cat" 4 is more about form than ultimate function. Now, a potential con: The suede. It's a magnet for dust, and you have to be careful with water. Not a "beat 'em up" daily shoe. Also, the breathability isn't great—it's a warm shoe. If you have wide feet, the fit might be snug. The $210 USD price tag is steep for an all-black shoe, no doubt. Now, a potential con: maintenance. This black nubuck is a dirt and scuff magnet. A slight brush against something, and you'll see a mark. If you're someone who likes to keep your kicks pristine, this might cause some anxiety. They're gonna require a bit more care than a leather pair.
